{
    "judgments": [
        {
            "dependent": "ProductDescription",
            "decision": "approve",
            "confidence": 0.88,
            "reason_code": "identifier_determines_descriptor",
            "reason_refers_to": null,
            "rationale": "A product model carries one marketing description shared by its variants. Across the repeated models, ProductKey, ProductSize and ProductColor all moved while the description never did, so it is not a variant-level value.",
            "request_escalation": false,
            "claims": {
                "repetition": "repeated_owners",
                "population": "measured_eligible_rows",
                "collision": null,
                "scope_claim": {
                    "basis": "observed_in_evidence",
                    "coordinates": [
                        "ProductKey",
                        "ProductSize",
                        "ProductColor"
                    ],
                    "evidence_refs": [
                        "measured_shape.coordinate_diversity"
                    ]
                },
                "evidence_refs": [
                    "candidate",
                    "measured_shape",
                    "paired_values",
                    "other_columns_in_this_table"
                ]
            },
            "scope": {
                "owning_determinant": [
                    "ModelName"
                ],
                "interpretation": "entity_property",
                "population": "all_eligible_rows",
                "conditions": [],
                "basis": "A product model's description is written once for the model and every size or colour variant row repeats it. The rows are product variants, not events or versions.",
                "evidence": [
                    "measured_shape",
                    "paired_values",
                    "other_columns_in_this_table"
                ]
            }
        },
        {
            "dependent": "ProductSubcategoryKey",
            "decision": "approve",
            "confidence": 0.85,
            "reason_code": "stable_reference_mapping",
            "reason_refers_to": null,
            "rationale": "Each product model sits in one catalogue subcategory, and its size, colour and SKU variants inherit that placement. Several models sharing a subcategory is the normal many-to-one shape and does not count against this pair.",
            "request_escalation": false,
            "claims": {
                "repetition": "repeated_owners",
                "population": "measured_eligible_rows",
                "collision": {
                    "direction": "reverse",
                    "columns": [
                        "ProductSubcategoryKey"
                    ],
                    "conflicting_values": [
                        "33"
                    ],
                    "evidence_refs": [
                        "paired_values"
                    ],
                    "basis": "observed_in_evidence"
                },
                "scope_claim": {
                    "basis": "observed_in_evidence",
                    "coordinates": [
                        "ProductKey",
                        "ProductSize",
                        "ProductColor"
                    ],
                    "evidence_refs": [
                        "measured_shape.coordinate_diversity"
                    ]
                },
                "evidence_refs": [
                    "candidate",
                    "measured_shape",
                    "paired_values",
                    "other_columns_in_this_table"
                ]
            },
            "scope": {
                "owning_determinant": [
                    "ModelName"
                ],
                "interpretation": "organizational_assignment",
                "population": "all_eligible_rows",
                "conditions": [],
                "basis": "The catalogue assigns each model to one subcategory, and its variant rows inherit that assignment. The models headlights - dual-beam and headlights - weatherproof both carrying 33 is the ordinary shared-dependent shape.",
                "evidence": [
                    "measured_shape",
                    "paired_values",
                    "other_columns_in_this_table"
                ]
            }
        }
    ]
}