```json { "judgments": [ { "dependent": "Country Code", "decision": "veto", "confidence": 0.88, "reason_code": "temporal_determinant", "reason_refers_to": "Longitude", "rationale": "Longitude is a coordinate, not a lookup key; nothing about a geographic position determines what happened there.", "request_escalation": false, "claims": { "repetition": "repeated_owners", "population": "measured_eligible_rows", "collision": { "direction": "forward", "columns": ["Country Code"], "conflicting_values": ["1", "94", "191"], "evidence_refs": ["violating_groups"], "basis": "observed_in_evidence" }, "scope_claim": null, "evidence_refs": ["candidate", "violating_groups", "measured_shape"] }, "scope": { "owning_determinant": ["Restaurant ID"], "interpretation": "unknown", "population": "all_eligible_rows", "conditions": [], "basis": "Longitude 0.0 carries three countries across 498 rows; this is missing data (geocoding failures) rather than a rule, and longitude generally does not determine country.", "evidence": ["violating_groups", "other_columns_in_this_table"] } }, { "dependent": "Currency", "decision": "veto", "confidence": 0.88, "reason_code": "temporal_determinant", "reason_refers_to": "Longitude", "rationale": "Longitude is a coordinate, not a lookup key; nothing about a geographic position determines currency.", "request_escalation": false, "claims": { "repetition": "repeated_owners", "population": "measured_eligible_rows", "collision": { "direction": "forward", "columns": ["Currency"], "conflicting_values": ["Indian Rupees(Rs.)", "Indonesian Rupiah(IDR)", "Sri Lankan Rupee(LKR)"], "evidence_refs": ["violating_groups"], "basis": "observed_in_evidence" }, "scope_claim": null, "evidence_refs": ["candidate", "violating_groups", "measured_shape"] }, "scope": { "owning_determinant": ["Restaurant ID"], "interpretation": "unknown", "population": "all_eligible_rows", "conditions": [], "basis": "Longitude 0.0 carries three currencies across 498 rows; this is missing data rather than a rule, and longitude does not determine currency.", "evidence": ["violating_groups", "other_columns_in_this_table"] } }, { "dependent": "Has Online delivery", "decision": "veto", "confidence": 0.91, "reason_code": "violations_spread_across_groups", "reason_refers_to": null, "rationale": "229 of 560 repeated groups disagree (41%), concentration 0.0058; this is how the column behaves, not dirt on a rule.", "request_escalation": false, "claims": { "repetition": "repeated_owners", "population": "measured_eligible_rows", "collision": { "direction": "forward", "columns": ["Has Online delivery"], "conflicting_values": ["False", "True"], "evidence_refs": ["violating_groups"], "basis": "observed_in_evidence" }, "scope_claim": { "basis": "observed_in_evidence", "coordinates": ["Restaurant ID"], "evidence_refs": ["measured_shape"] }, "evidence_refs": ["candidate", "violating_groups", "measured_shape"] }, "scope": { "owning_determinant": ["Restaurant ID"], "interpretation": "transaction_value", "population": "all_eligible_rows", "conditions": [], "basis": "Restaurant ID varies inside 560 longitude groups and the dependent moves with it in 229; online delivery is a per-restaurant property, not a location property.", "evidence": ["measured_shape", "other_columns_in_this_table"] } }, { "dependent": "Has Table booking", "decision": "veto", "confidence": 0.90, "reason_code": "violations_spread_across_groups", "reason_refers_to": null, "rationale": "166 of 560 repeated groups disagree (30%), concentration 0.0129; systematic disagreement, not isolated dirt.", "request_escalation": false, "claims": { "repetition": "repeated_owners", "population": "measured_eligible_rows", "collision": { "direction": "forward", "columns": ["Has Table booking"], "conflicting_values": ["False", "True"], "evidence_refs": ["violating_groups"], "basis": "observed_in_evidence" }, "scope_claim": { "basis": "observed_in_evidence", "coordinates": ["Restaurant ID"], "evidence_refs": ["measured_shape"] }, "evidence_refs": ["candidate", "violating_groups", "measured_shape"] }, "scope": { "owning_determinant": ["Restaurant ID"], "interpretation": "transaction_value", "population": "all_eligible_rows", "conditions": [], "basis": "Restaurant ID varies inside 560 longitude groups and the dependent moves with it in 166; table booking is a per-restaurant property, not a location property.", "evidence": ["measured_shape", "other_columns_in_this_table"] } }, { "dependent": "Is delivering now", "decision": "veto", "confidence": 0.85, "reason_code": "temporal_determinant", "reason_refers_to": "Longitude", "rationale": "Longitude is a coordinate; 'Is delivering now' is a time-dependent status that cannot be determined by location alone.", "request_escalation": false, "claims": { "repetition": "repeated_owners", "population": "measured_eligible_rows", "collision": { "direction": "forward", "columns": ["Is delivering now"], "conflicting_values": ["False", "True"], "evidence_refs": ["violating_groups"], "basis": "observed_in_evidence" }, "scope_claim": { "basis": "observed_in_evidence", "coordinates": ["Restaurant ID"], "evidence_refs": ["measured_shape"] }, "evidence_refs": ["candidate", "violating_groups", "measured_shape"] }, "scope": { "owning_determinant": ["Restaurant ID"], "interpretation": "transaction_value", "population": "all_eligible_rows", "conditions": [], "basis": "Restaurant ID varies inside 560 longitude groups and the dependent moves with it in 5; 'delivering now' is a temporal status per restaurant, not a location property.", "evidence": ["measured_shape", "other_columns_in_this_table"] } } ] } ```