{
    "judgments": [
        {
            "dependent": "ProductStyle",
            "decision": "rescue",
            "confidence": 0.82,
            "reason_code": "dominant_majority_dirty_rows",
            "reason_refers_to": null,
            "rationale": "One model, \"ML Mountain Frame-W\", carries \"U\" on a single row against four rows of \"W\" — and the model name itself denotes the women's frame, so the stray row is a bad style code, not a second correct style.",
            "request_escalation": false,
            "claims": {
                "repetition": "repeated_owners",
                "population": "measured_eligible_rows",
                "collision": {
                    "direction": "forward",
                    "columns": [
                        "ProductStyle"
                    ],
                    "conflicting_values": [
                        "W",
                        "U"
                    ],
                    "evidence_refs": [
                        "violating_groups",
                        "measured_shape.forward_violations"
                    ],
                    "basis": "observed_in_evidence"
                },
                "scope_claim": null,
                "evidence_refs": [
                    "candidate",
                    "violating_groups",
                    "measured_shape",
                    "other_columns_in_this_table"
                ]
            },
            "scope": {
                "owning_determinant": [
                    "ModelName"
                ],
                "interpretation": "entity_property",
                "population": "all_eligible_rows",
                "conditions": [],
                "basis": "Each row is one catalogue product (ProductKey is the declared primary key, 293 distinct SKUs over 119 models, no date or snapshot column), so a model's style designation is a fixed property of the model; ProductKey, ProductSKU, ProductName and ProductColor all varied inside 37/15 model groups while the style moved in only one, which is the variation that would have broken a model-level rule.",
                "evidence": [
                    "other_columns_in_this_table",
                    "measured_shape.coordinate_diversity",
                    "measured_shape.counts",
                    "forward_violations.witnesses"
                ]
            }
        }
    ]
}