{"judgments":[{"dependent":"CustomerKey","decision":"approve","confidence":0.92,"reason_code":"identifier_determines_descriptor","reason_refers_to":null,"rationale":"An order header is placed by one customer, and the rows are order lines. Across 16,919 multi-line orders the customer never changed, even while line item, product and stock date varied.","request_escalation":false,"claims":{"repetition":"repeated_owners","population":"measured_eligible_rows","collision":null,"scope_claim":{"basis":"observed_in_evidence","coordinates":["OrderLineItem","ProductKey","StockDate"],"evidence_refs":["measured_shape.coordinate_diversity"]},"evidence_refs":["candidate","measured_shape","other_columns_in_this_table"]},"scope":{"owning_determinant":["OrderNumber"],"interpretation":"entity_property","population":"all_eligible_rows","conditions":[],"basis":"The customer is fixed when the order is placed. Each row is a line of an order, so the repeated lines restate the same customer rather than revising it.","evidence":["candidate","measured_shape","other_columns_in_this_table"]}}},{"dependent":"OrderDate","decision":"approve","confidence":0.9,"reason_code":"identifier_determines_descriptor","reason_refers_to":null,"rationale":"An order is placed on one date, and the rows are that order's lines. The date stayed fixed across 16,919 multi-line orders while product, line item and stock date varied.","request_escalation":false,"claims":{"repetition":"repeated_owners","population":"measured_eligible_rows","collision":null,"scope_claim":{"basis":"observed_in_evidence","coordinates":["OrderLineItem","ProductKey","StockDate"],"evidence_refs":["measured_shape.coordinate_diversity"]},"evidence_refs":["candidate","measured_shape","other_columns_in_this_table"]},"scope":{"owning_determinant":["OrderNumber"],"interpretation":"entity_property","population":"all_eligible_rows","conditions":[],"basis":"The order date is a header attribute of the order. The repeated lines re-state it, and the line-level columns that do vary never moved it.","evidence":["candidate","measured_shape","other_columns_in_this_table"]}}},{"dependent":"TerritoryKey","decision":"approve","confidence":0.85,"reason_code":"identifier_determines_descriptor","reason_refers_to":null,"rationale":"An order is booked to one sales territory. The territory stayed fixed across 16,919 multi-line orders while product and line item varied. It may be inherited through the customer, which was not judged here.","request_escalation":false,"claims":{"repetition":"repeated_owners","population":"measured_eligible_rows","collision":null,"scope_claim":{"basis":"observed_in_evidence","coordinates":["OrderLineItem","ProductKey","StockDate"],"evidence_refs":["measured_shape.coordinate_diversity"]},"evidence_refs":["candidate","measured_shape","competing_owners_for_this_dependent"]},"scope":{"owning_determinant":["OrderNumber"],"interpretation":"entity_property","population":"all_eligible_rows","conditions":[],"basis":"Territory is a header-level attribute of the order. CustomerKey also determines it in this extract, so it may be inherited through the customer, but the order-level rule stands either way.","evidence":["candidate","measured_shape","competing_owners_for_this_dependent"]}}},{"dependent":"Year","decision":"approve","confidence":0.88,"reason_code":"identifier_determines_descriptor","reason_refers_to":null,"rationale":"Year follows from the order date, so every line of an order carries one year. The rule holds by inheritance through OrderDate, which OrderNumber determines.","request_escalation":false,"claims":{"repetition":"repeated_owners","population":"measured_eligible_rows","collision":null,"scope_claim":{"basis":"observed_in_evidence","coordinates":["OrderLineItem","ProductKey","StockDate"],"evidence_refs":["measured_shape.coordinate_diversity"]},"evidence_refs":["candidate","measured_shape","competing_owners_for_this_dependent"]},"scope":{"owning_determinant":["OrderDate"],"interpretation":"entity_property","population":"all_eligible_rows","conditions":[],"basis":"A year is a coarsening of the order date, and OrderDate determines Year in this table. OrderNumber reaches Year through OrderDate, so the pair is a true inherited rule rather than a coincidence.","evidence":["candidate","measured_shape","competing_owners_for_this_dependent"]}}}]}