{
    "judgments": [
        {
            "dependent": "away_own_goal",
            "decision": "veto",
            "confidence": 0.85,
            "reason_code": "coincidental_cooccurrence",
            "reason_refers_to": null,
            "rationale": "An own goal by the away side belongs to a match, not to the home captain. The rule only looks near-true because most matches record no such event; the non-empty entries are real events, not typos.",
            "request_escalation": false,
            "claims": {
                "repetition": "repeated_owners",
                "population": "measured_eligible_rows",
                "collision": {
                    "direction": "forward",
                    "columns": [
                        "away_own_goal"
                    ],
                    "conflicting_values": [
                        "",
                        "Jimmy Dickinson (OG) · 94"
                    ],
                    "evidence_refs": [
                        "violating_groups"
                    ],
                    "basis": "observed_in_evidence"
                },
                "scope_claim": null,
                "evidence_refs": [
                    "candidate",
                    "violating_groups"
                ]
            }
        },
        {
            "dependent": "away_penalty",
            "decision": "veto",
            "confidence": 0.85,
            "reason_code": "coincidental_cooccurrence",
            "reason_refers_to": null,
            "rationale": "Away penalty shootout counts belong to the match. Home_captain does not own them, and the NULL-dominant groups are an artifact of most matches having no shootout.",
            "request_escalation": false,
            "claims": {
                "repetition": "repeated_owners",
                "population": "measured_eligible_rows",
                "collision": {
                    "direction": "forward",
                    "columns": [
                        "away_penalty"
                    ],
                    "conflicting_values": [
                        "NULL",
                        "2"
                    ],
                    "evidence_refs": [
                        "violating_groups"
                    ],
                    "basis": "observed_in_evidence"
                },
                "scope_claim": null,
                "evidence_refs": [
                    "candidate",
                    "violating_groups"
                ]
            }
        },
        {
            "dependent": "away_penalty_miss_long",
            "decision": "veto",
            "confidence": 0.85,
            "reason_code": "coincidental_cooccurrence",
            "reason_refers_to": null,
            "rationale": "Penalty-miss details are per-match events. The odd rows are genuine events in specific matches, so quarantining them would delete real data. The captain does not own this value.",
            "request_escalation": false,
            "claims": {
                "repetition": "repeated_owners",
                "population": "measured_eligible_rows",
                "collision": {
                    "direction": "forward",
                    "columns": [
                        "away_penalty_miss_long"
                    ],
                    "conflicting_values": [
                        "",
                        "['10’|0:0|Alphonso Davies|Penalty saved by Thibaut Courtois']"
                    ],
                    "evidence_refs": [
                        "violating_groups"
                    ],
                    "basis": "observed_in_evidence"
                },
                "scope_claim": null,
                "evidence_refs": [
                    "candidate",
                    "violating_groups"
                ]
            }
        },
        {
            "dependent": "away_penalty_shootout_goal_long",
            "decision": "veto",
            "confidence": 0.87,
            "reason_code": "coincidental_cooccurrence",
            "reason_refers_to": null,
            "rationale": "Shootout sequences describe a specific match, not a captain. The minority values are distinct real shootouts, not misspellings of the blank majority.",
            "request_escalation": false,
            "claims": {
                "repetition": "repeated_owners",
                "population": "measured_eligible_rows",
                "collision": {
                    "direction": "forward",
                    "columns": [
                        "away_penalty_shootout_goal_long"
                    ],
                    "conflicting_values": [
                        "",
                        "['1|0:1|Kylian Mbappé', '7|3:2|Randal Kolo Muani']"
                    ],
                    "evidence_refs": [
                        "violating_groups"
                    ],
                    "basis": "observed_in_evidence"
                },
                "scope_claim": null,
                "evidence_refs": [
                    "candidate",
                    "violating_groups"
                ]
            }
        },
        {
            "dependent": "away_penalty_shootout_miss_long",
            "decision": "veto",
            "confidence": 0.87,
            "reason_code": "coincidental_cooccurrence",
            "reason_refers_to": null,
            "rationale": "Shootout miss lists are match events. The same captain appears with blank and with real event values, and these are true per-match differences rather than dirt.",
            "request_escalation": false,
            "claims": {
                "repetition": "repeated_owners",
                "population": "measured_eligible_rows",
                "collision": {
                    "direction": "forward",
                    "columns": [
                        "away_penalty_shootout_miss_long"
                    ],
                    "conflicting_values": [
                        "",
                        "['3|1:1|Kingsley Coman', '5|2:1|Aurélien Tchouaméni']"
                    ],
                    "evidence_refs": [
                        "violating_groups"
                    ],
                    "basis": "observed_in_evidence"
                },
                "scope_claim": null,
                "evidence_refs": [
                    "candidate",
                    "violating_groups"
                ]
            }
        },
        {
            "dependent": "away_yellow_red_card",
            "decision": "veto",
            "confidence": 0.85,
            "reason_code": "coincidental_cooccurrence",
            "reason_refers_to": null,
            "rationale": "A second-yellow dismissal is an event in one match. It is not a property of the home captain, and the non-blank values are real events, not errors.",
            "request_escalation": false,
            "claims": {
                "repetition": "repeated_owners",
                "population": "measured_eligible_rows",
                "collision": {
                    "direction": "forward",
                    "columns": [
                        "away_yellow_red_card"
                    ],
                    "conflicting_values": [
                        "",
                        "Igor Smolnikov · 36"
                    ],
                    "evidence_refs": [
                        "violating_groups"
                    ],
                    "basis": "observed_in_evidence"
                },
                "scope_claim": null,
                "evidence_refs": [
                    "candidate",
                    "violating_groups"
                ]
            }
        },
        {
            "dependent": "home_own_goal",
            "decision": "veto",
            "confidence": 0.87,
            "reason_code": "coincidental_cooccurrence",
            "reason_refers_to": null,
            "rationale": "Own goals are per-match events. One captain spans many matches with differing outcomes, so the blank majority is absence of an event and the minority rows are real.",
            "request_escalation": false,
            "claims": {
                "repetition": "repeated_owners",
                "population": "measured_eligible_rows",
                "collision": {
                    "direction": "forward",
                    "columns": [
                        "home_own_goal"
                    ],
                    "conflicting_values": [
                        "",
                        "Denis Cheryshev (OG) · 23"
                    ],
                    "evidence_refs": [
                        "violating_groups"
                    ],
                    "basis": "observed_in_evidence"
                },
                "scope_claim": null,
                "evidence_refs": [
                    "candidate",
                    "violating_groups"
                ]
            }
        },
        {
            "dependent": "home_penalty",
            "decision": "veto",
            "confidence": 0.85,
            "reason_code": "coincidental_cooccurrence",
            "reason_refers_to": null,
            "rationale": "Home shootout penalty counts belong to individual matches. They are NULL for most rows and real counts elsewhere, so the captain does not determine them.",
            "request_escalation": false,
            "claims": {
                "repetition": "repeated_owners",
                "population": "measured_eligible_rows",
                "collision": {
                    "direction": "forward",
                    "columns": [
                        "home_penalty"
                    ],
                    "conflicting_values": [
                        "NULL",
                        "4"
                    ],
                    "evidence_refs": [
                        "violating_groups"
                    ],
                    "basis": "observed_in_evidence"
                },
                "scope_claim": null,
                "evidence_refs": [
                    "candidate",
                    "violating_groups"
                ]
            }
        },
        {
            "dependent": "home_penalty_shootout_goal_long",
            "decision": "veto",
            "confidence": 0.87,
            "reason_code": "coincidental_cooccurrence",
            "reason_refers_to": null,
            "rationale": "Shootout goal sequences are details of a single match. Blank against a full sequence is absence versus presence of a shootout, not dirt on a captain-level rule.",
            "request_escalation": false,
            "claims": {
                "repetition": "repeated_owners",
                "population": "measured_eligible_rows",
                "collision": {
                    "direction": "forward",
                    "columns": [
                        "home_penalty_shootout_goal_long"
                    ],
                    "conflicting_values": [
                        "",
                        "['1|1:0|Franco Baresi', '3|2:1|Roberto Baggio', '5|3:2|Luigi De Agostini']"
                    ],
                    "evidence_refs": [
                        "violating_groups"
                    ],
                    "basis": "observed_in_evidence"
                },
                "scope_claim": null,
                "evidence_refs": [
                    "candidate",
                    "violating_groups"
                ]
            }
        },
        {
            "dependent": "home_penalty_shootout_miss_long",
            "decision": "veto",
            "confidence": 0.87,
            "reason_code": "coincidental_cooccurrence",
            "reason_refers_to": null,
            "rationale": "Shootout miss lists are match events. Quarantining the minority rows would delete real shootouts, and the captain does not own the value.",
            "request_escalation": false,
            "claims": {
                "repetition": "repeated_owners",
                "population": "measured_eligible_rows",
                "collision": {
                    "direction": "forward",
                    "columns": [
                        "home_penalty_shootout_miss_long"
                    ],
                    "conflicting_values": [
                        "",
                        "['1|0:0|Sócrates', '9|3:3|Júlio César']"
                    ],
                    "evidence_refs": [
                        "violating_groups"
                    ],
                    "basis": "observed_in_evidence"
                },
                "scope_claim": null,
                "evidence_refs": [
                    "candidate",
                    "violating_groups"
                ]
            }
        },
        {
            "dependent": "home_red_card",
            "decision": "veto",
            "confidence": 0.87,
            "reason_code": "coincidental_cooccurrence",
            "reason_refers_to": null,
            "rationale": "A red card is a per-match event, not a property of the captain. The non-blank entries are real dismissals in specific matches, so they are not typos to quarantine.",
            "request_escalation": false,
            "claims": {
                "repetition": "repeated_owners",
                "population": "measured_eligible_rows",
                "collision": {
                    "direction": "forward",
                    "columns": [
                        "home_red_card"
                    ],
                    "conflicting_values": [
                        "",
                        "Diego Maradona · 85"
                    ],
                    "evidence_refs": [
                        "violating_groups"
                    ],
                    "basis": "observed_in_evidence"
                },
                "scope_claim": null,
                "evidence_refs": [
                    "candidate",
                    "violating_groups"
                ]
            }
        },
        {
            "dependent": "home_yellow_red_card",
            "decision": "veto",
            "confidence": 0.85,
            "reason_code": "coincidental_cooccurrence",
            "reason_refers_to": null,
            "rationale": "Second-yellow dismissals happen within a match and vary between a captain's matches. Blank versus a named player is absence versus presence of an event, not dirt.",
            "request_escalation": false,
            "claims": {
                "repetition": "repeated_owners",
                "population": "measured_eligible_rows",
                "collision": {
                    "direction": "forward",
                    "columns": [
                        "home_yellow_red_card"
                    ],
                    "conflicting_values": [
                        "",
                        "Eric Gerets · 42"
                    ],
                    "evidence_refs": [
                        "violating_groups"
                    ],
                    "basis": "observed_in_evidence"
                },
                "scope_claim": null,
                "evidence_refs": [
                    "candidate",
                    "violating_groups"
                ]
            }
        }
    ]
}